Jim was killed in 1884 after it was determined he used his saloon as a cover to kidnap and poison patrons, relieving them of their money and valuables. In 2016 Jim is seen running an underground fight club. Xavier Dolls and Doc Holliday go to him in order to find out the location of Jack of Knives and he makes them fight in his club. Afterwards he is captured by Black Badge Division and used for research and information. He is killed by Willa Earp shooting him with Peacemaker.